ffmpeg can cut off the end of a transparent VP9

It’s a current bug

tl;dr: use -lag-in-frames 0 as a workaround for now

I have been creating stinger transitions for my stream. These are animated transparent transitions that switch out scenes when at least one frame has no transparency.

Example stinger from A ? B ? A
Example stinger from A ? B ? A

I’ve been using Blender to create the animations, and ffmpeg to encode the images into a video. The VP9 encoder can handle transparent videos, so the command looks like:

ffmpeg -framerate 60 -f image2 -i frame%04d.png -c:v libvpx-vp9 -pix_fmt yuva420p -an -lossless 1 stinger.webm

However, my latest stinger was slightly longer than others at five seconds. I noticed that it was ending a few frames too early. Thanks to Carl on the ffmpeg-user mailing list it was pointed out that this is a known bug.

In the Trac ticket a user called User posits the problem is with lag-in-frames; by setting it to 0 the correct number of frames are output.

Tell us what's on your mind